The traditional linguists pay a little interest in structure of language but dedicate time to study grammatical forms, such as definition for parts of speech or word order, because they believe that language is the set of rules. The study conforms to the diachronic study – the study of the occurrence as it changes through time – by comparing the changes of language from the ancient into the present day. As a consequence of diachronic study, there are only correct and incorrect in using language since the traditional linguists try to prescribe the directions by sticking to the rules for the accurate use of the language. Therefore, using language that does not fit to the rules of universal grammar is unacceptable.
The goal of traditional grammar method is to appreciate the aesthetics of the language not to communicate with each other. The traditional linguists concern about the usage of its ...
... middle of paper ...
... structure does not consider the meaning of representation which makes possible to the misunderstanding of sentences.
There are some other differences between these two theories. Although using L1 in traditional teaching is easy to make the students understand to what the teacher has said, but the lesson itself is very tedious. Whereas, using L2 in structural teaching is very advantageous but it held that consume a lot of time. Because L2 is the whole new world to the students so they need more time to achieve that. However, many types of equipment, e.g., recorded tapes with the native speaking, sound-lab rooms, visual aids, are required in teaching to help the students accomplish the goal of structuralism.
Even if there are some of drawbacks, there are some of virtues for both of theories as well. Because there is nothing in this world that created perfectly.
Need Writing Help?
Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.Check your paper »
- Grammar has two primary approaches—prescriptive and descriptive. Prescriptive grammar is the general approach of right versus wrong, and historically the kind of approach overzealous English teachers apply to their students. Popular culture has lovingly deemed the rigid prescriptive grammarian the “Grammar Nazi,” which actually refers to the grade school graduate who clings tightly to the Latin based traditional rules and enforces those rules online. Due to these perspectives and due to various studies performed in classrooms, many have been rebuffing the study of grammar in schools.... [tags: Grammar and Writing]
2583 words (7.4 pages)
- A. Introduction Conditional sentences are dedicated to expressing a possible situation and its consequences. Teaching of conditional sentences is a difficult point in secondary school English education. In mainland China, students begin the learning of the first and zero type of conditional sentences in the eighth grade, and learn the rest of second and third type of condition sentences in the eleventh grade. The long learning period of conditional sentence can reflect the great importance and difficulty of teaching this grammar.... [tags: education, grammar, teaching method]
2198 words (6.3 pages)
- Cries of, “But when will we ever use this in real life?” resound through classrooms, debilitating teachers in their pursuit of student excellence. Once a staple in schools, grammar has become anathema to the standard course of English instruction. With the advent of the impending pertinence of the "real world," the tediousness and technicality of the study of grammar has undergone microscopic scrutiny. The real world forces people to face technical and tedious situations sometimes, however. Thus, the technical construct of grammar should not be grounds for its immediate dismissal.... [tags: debilitating teachers, students excellence]
1322 words (3.8 pages)
- ... It is assume that living in the United States and going to an American would provide students with the verbal practice they need, but the realization is that it does not. Students are missing a key portion of learning grammar due to a lack of practice. There are also nonverbal areas in ESOL classrooms that are missing key parts of information. When teaching students grammar rules and tricks it should be explained that when and where they work and when and where they do not work. I have learned this from experience because I was taught grammar rules in the United States when studying English that are not always applicable or correct.... [tags: Education, Linguistics, Noam Chomsky, Teacher]
1461 words (4.2 pages)
- The Systematic Teaching of Grammar: A Critique From the writer: "The Systematic Teaching of Grammar: A Critique" is a piece that was written for my Peer Writing Consultant class, WRT 331. The assignment was rather open, we were to relate our experiences as a writing consultant to an area interest. I was inspired to choose grammar as my subject area because I found that many students came to me asking directly for help with their grammar. This piece was more of an exploratory piece than anything else.... [tags: Essays Papers]
2516 words (7.2 pages)
- Part A 1. Introduction Teaching English If-conditional sentences to Chinese students is always a challenge for English teachers. English teachers are still continuously seeking for an effective method to make the language point more understandable for students. The probability approach put forward by Mei Wu (2012) provides a clear classification of conditional sentences. Based on her theory, conditional sentences can be mainly divided into four types. In terms of probability, type 1 is the factual conditionals (zero condition) which mean the event is definitely happen to meet the condition stated in the if-clause.... [tags: education, grammar, language learning]
1978 words (5.7 pages)
- A. Introduction As guides, teachers play a significant role in imparting grammar knowledge to students. They use their existing knowledge to enhance students’ learning ability during the process of their teaching. As regard to which method should teachers adopt, many researchers hold different views. In this article, the author mainly discusses the strategies in teaching passive voice by evaluating Miss Wong’s pedagogical approach. In the second part, the author will write a proposal to suggest an alternative teaching method regarding passive voice.... [tags: education, language, grammar, student]
1975 words (5.6 pages)
- Introduction It has been well documented that there are three main kinds of conditional sentence. The first one is the verb in the main clause is “will” or “shall” and the verb in the conditional clause is in the simple present tense. Secondly, in the main clause the verb is “should” or “would” and in the conditional clause the verb is in the simple past tense. Last but not the least, the verb in the principle clause is “should have” or “would have” while in the conditional clause is in the past perfect tense (Sinclair, 2011).... [tags: grammar, student learning, teaching method]
1963 words (5.6 pages)
- Grammar is traditionally subdivided into two areas of study – morphology and syntax. Morphology is the study of how words are formed out of smaller units, syntax studies the way in which phrases and sentences are structured out of words. Traditional grammar describes the syntax of a language in terms of a taxonomy (classification). This approach is based on the assumption that phrases and sentences are built up of a series of constituents, each of which belongs to a specific grammatical category and serves a specific grammatical function.... [tags: grammar, native language, syntax]
935 words (2.7 pages)
- Total Physical Response Method and Spanish Teaching strategies of a foreign language class have evolved from a long history of useless methods that do not fulfill the goal of language acquisition. The main goal of a foreign language class in terms of the New Jersey Core Curriculum Standards is that the students be able to communicate using the foreign language. Communication refers to the student’s ability to converse with a native speaker of the language that has been studied. In the past, it was assumed that students must first learn the rules of grammar and then use those rules to construct sentences and communicate, but there have been several linguistic theories that have refuted this... [tags: Foreign Languages Education Essays]
1355 words (3.9 pages)